This will provide a clearer picture of how many employees are earning the highest salaries and might be eligible for an early retirement or buyout offer. And our data confirm that teachers in this group were substantially more likely to leave the Illinois school system once ERI went into effect. Your full basic and lump sum pension for comparison. Our estimates indicate that, for each teacher who left under the ERI, test scores increased by 0.01 and 0.04 student-level standard deviations in math and reading, respectively. Howard County saved about $4.3 million in the first year after the buyout. If the experienced teachers who retire are more effective than the new hires, teacher retirements could reduce student achievement. To measure the effect on test scores of the retirements resulting from the ERI program, we exploit the fact that teachers with more years of experience were much more likely to be affected by the program. But ultimately it comes down to some district-specific calculations, says Domenech says, of AASA. For me to retire at 45, I would see my pension drop 2/3rd from $58,000 a year to $18,000 a year. We focus our analysis on the 1989–90 through 1996–97 school years, because the earliest available data are from the 1989–90 school year, and in 1998 the Illinois legislature changed the teacher benefit formula in ways that could influence teacher retirement decisions. Create a mock retirement budget. For most, it determines if you are eligible to receive a pension at all. Despite Success in New York City, It’s Time for Charters to Guard Their Flanks. These data let us follow an employee across schools and as she enters and exits IPS. In Illinois, the state, rather than the districts, must make up the increased costs to the pension system of these ERI retirees. Employee contributions are made over the course of employment, and benefits are paid out upon retirement. The fee for employees was 4 percent of the highest annual salary for each of the additional years of age and service purchased; the fee for employers was 12 percent of the employee’s highest annual salary for each year purchased. If not, then you are not alone. The state sets specific windows when teachers can retire with benefits based on age and years of experience. Her salary this year, her last year of teaching, was $50,000. Because of the ERI, the median teacher retired 5 years earlier than she would have otherwise, at age 55 with 27 years of service rather than at age 60 with 32 years of service. Even though it is an informal letter, it should be written with professionalism, and not have an overly casual tone. [email protected], University of Chicago Press(for subscription service to the printed journal) For me early retirement has a number of meanings. Even of those who want to retire from teaching between 61 and 64, there are only 16% who know that they can afford to leave then. Since we find no support for the notion that schools reduced pupil-teacher ratios in order to counteract the potential negative impact of teacher retirements, we suspect that the teachers who took up the ERI were less effective than the ones who replaced them or than the ones remaining in the school. You may find retirement enjoyable for a few months, but without a new project to work on, too much leisure time may get old for you. * Premature retirement reached a peak in 1997, when about 19,000 teachers in England and Wales left the profession * The exodus followed a fall in school rolls - and an announcement of impending curbs on early retirement. The opportunity for teachers to retire early exacerbates the measurement challenge, as early retirement programs give teachers greater flexibility in deciding when they leave teaching. The median ERI retiree received $115,677 of increased benefits from retiring five years earlier. As public budgets have grown tighter over the past decade, states and school districts have sought ways to control the growth of spending. In 1992–93 and 1993–94, employees were offered an ERI as an alternative to the standard early-retirement option. Last year, Dubuque Community Schools more than doubled its average number of retirees through what would be considered a classic early retirement incentive. We find the program did not reduce test scores; likely, it increased them, with positive effects most pronounced in schools that serve a more disadvantaged student population. This may be particularly true for those teachers who desire to retire early. Teachers in Washington's Tier 2 plan can retire with full benefits at age 65 with at least 5 years of experience. First, the Teacher Service Record (TSR) is an administrative data set that tracks where IPS employees work and their number of years of creditable experience in the retirement system. However, there could have been different effects in different schools that were driven, at least in part, by the fact that wealthier or higher-achieving schools may find it easier to replace retiring teachers with experienced teachers from other schools. Know your service credit. The second set of data includes school-level information on test scores for certain grades and subjects, collected since the early 1990s as part of Illinois’ ongoing accountability program. Cash payments or health insurance benefits for teachers willing to retire a few years earlier than they might otherwise. Teachers who retired early because of the ERI, however, could expect to receive pension benefits for more years than if they had retired later. As a result, schools with many veteran teachers saw large declines in teacher experience when the ERI went into effect. Differences across schools in treatment intensity enable us to measure the impact of ERI-induced retirements on test scores. In other words, schools with more veteran teachers before the creation of the ERI program experienced much larger changes in teacher turnover and declines in teacher experience when the program was implemented than schools with fewer such teachers. “If you retire just before filling out the Fafsa, there’s going to be a lot of income showing up there,” Northrup says. Incentive programs for veteran teachers may boost student achievement. In 2010 alone, several large states, including New York, Michigan, and Minnesota, enacted ERI legislation. Administrators at the district of 76 schools twice contemplated—and decided against—offering an incentive in the last decade, before finally crafting a buyout plan in the 2014-15 school year that would save the district an estimated $11.4 million over eight years. An early retirement option exists, whereby members who are at least 55 years old and who have at least 20 years of service can receive their full benefit if both the employee and the employer pay a one-time fee. The aging of the nation’s teacher workforce underscores the importance of examining how ERI programs influence student learning. Although retirements under the ERI program occurred quickly and unexpectedly, the possibility remains that administrators made changes in areas other than their teaching staffs to compensate for the loss of experienced teachers. Before examining how the ERI affected student academic achievement, it is important to understand how it affected schools through changes in retirement patterns, teacher-experience levels, and school resources. Teachers Consider ‘Temporary' Early Retirement to Avoid In-Classroom Teaching By Wayne Carter • Published June 24, 2020 • Updated on June 26, 2020 at 5:07 pm NBCUniversal, Inc. The results point to increases in student achievement from teacher retirement that are, if anything, larger for disadvantaged schools—the opposite of what we might have expected (see Figure 3). Phone (773) 753-3347, or toll-free in U.S. and Canada (877) 705-1878 If you are on that "edge" in your classroom and so ready to retire, here are 5 key points that are a must as you wind down your career of service as a teacher. Buyouts or similar cash incentives for those near the top of the pay scale who may not be close to retirement but may want to leave education or move to another district. How to retire early by not focusing on it at all. Members in the final salary arrangement can take up to two stages of phased retirement before the age of 60. So this year, the district, which has 36 teachers, offered an early-notification incentive. But Ms. Late tried various other careers before trying her hand at teaching at age 45. Addtionally, principals and administrators may respond to large losses of experienced teachers, such as by decreasing class sizes or changing the assignment of teachers to students. Taking into account both costs and savings across the approximately 8,000 teachers who took advantage of the Illinois program, ERI resulted in savings to IPS districts of $550.5 million. The earliest age at which retirement benefit collection could have taken place before the ERI is 55; with the ERI, teachers can retire at age 50 or older. There is a great deal of variation in the average experience of teachers across schools. To overcome this challenge, we take advantage of a natural experiment brought about by a two-year ERI program offered by Illinois in the early 1990s. In contrast, experience levels in schools with few veteran teachers increased slightly, as fewer of their teachers retired and those who remained gained experience (see Figure 2). The opportunity for teachers to retire early exacerbates the measurement challenge, as early retirement programs give teachers greater flexibility in deciding when they leave teaching. Emily Brandon, a reporter at US News, hands out some sage advice on what to expect when contemplating a late-life career in teaching. “It could become cyclical” he adds. But by the Nineties, a teacher surplus had turned into a teacher shortage - … If a district can get enough of its highest paid teachers to retire, the rule of thumb is that it can then hire two new teachers for the price of one, according to Dan Domenech, executive director of AASA, the School Superintendents Association. District Administration. But they point in a positive direction, and are precise enough that we can rule out the possibility that teacher departures due to the ERI had even small negative effects. On the one hand, retiring teachers are highly experienced, and they typically are replaced with much less experienced or new teachers. Should I retire early from teaching? Additionally, Washington allows early retirement. Taken together, the cost and benefit estimates suggest that taxpayers paid $51 per student in return for an increase in test scores of 1 percent of a standard deviation. The main assumption underlying our analysis is that, in the absence of the ERI program, schools with different teacher-experience levels in the pre-ERI period would have had the same trends in student test scores. This drop in average experience was driven in part by an increase in the number of new teachers. BrightBytes will continue to grow its education data analytics organization, which currently provides predictive analytics across school improvement, digital learning and student success, via its Clarity platform, With $20 million in voter-approved “innovation” funds as part of a $576.5 million bond issue, the Boulder Valley School District’s schools were tasked with integrating technology in curricula and rethinking […], Gail Pletnick, superintendent of Dysart Unified School District 89 in Surprise, Arizona, was elected president of AASA for 2016-17. However, according to U.S. News, retiring early has … For example, teachers may retire rather than face a lower-performing group of students. This short-term program led to the retirement of 10 percent of Illinois teachers in a two-year time span. If it means that much to you, you’ll make time for it. Rule of 90 allowed Minnesota public employees to retire with an unreduced pension once their years of service plus their age equaled 90. That’s because laws, union contracts, demographics, per-pupil spending and the ability to attract young and qualified replacement teachers vary so greatly from state to state. Tier 2 teachers can retire early at age 55 with at least 20 years of service. The letter should be written in business-letter style, and it may be acceptable to copy the letter to everyone via email, except the direct superior. First, we find that having one more teacher with 15 or more years of experience in a school before ERI increased the number of experienced teachers exiting each year during the ERI period by 33 percent. Early Retirement It‘s possible to take your benefits before you reach your Normal Pension Age (NPA) The age at which you're eligible to claim retirement benefits without actuarial reduction. We include in our study only those staff members who serve as regular classroom or special education teachers. We compare changes in student performance in schools that were more affected by the policy because they employed more experienced teachers to changes in schools that were less affected. Fax (617) 496-4428 “When you get people to retire early, you will have a diminished number of retirees in subsequent years” says Stan Rheingans, superintendent of Dubuque Community Schools in Iowa. Since there were approximately 1.8 million students in IPS in 1993, this represented a cost per student of $51. In 2010, more than one-third of teachers were over the age of 50. Several years ago, Upsala Area School District in Minnesota stopped offering early retirement incentives after multiple teachers approached the school board to individually negotiate packages. For some states, this number of years is used to determine the amount of the pension. “The worst thing you can do is offer a benefit and just get those who were going to retire anyway.”. The district announced the change a year before it took effect, and had a number of teachers retire that way, Lemle says. Both of these estimates are quite small, and only the estimate for reading is statistically significant. In the end, 395 employees did, of which 217 were teachers, says Davis, executive director of budget and finance. Email [email protected], Web-only content Copyright © 2020 President & Fellows of Harvard College. We also find that, while this particular program produced a net cost to taxpayers, it is likely that a carefully designed program could produce similar results at a lower cost. Without good planning, early retirement incentives can end up costing districts in the long run, both financially and academically. “A lot of times, districts don’t look at regular retirement numbers and end up just handing out an extra bonus” says Rose, of the Educators Preferred Corporation. The school districts also record attendance rates and grade-specific enrollment for each school and year. In Virginia, it’s not unheard of for teachers to retire from one district and then go work in another. I did see a thread somewhere else on MSE about teacher's pensions but cannot find it now. The procedure normally takes place over a long period of time with many internal procedures having to be completed. 79 JFK Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 Advice for those considering a career change to teaching prior to retirement. For each year of creditable service purchased through the ERI, however, the district has to pay 12 percent of the teacher’s salary in a lump-sum payment. Athletes and coaches of sports teams say it all the time: “The day I don’t feel like going to the gym (or field) is the day that I hang it up.” The same applies to teaching. These data include the percentage of students who are from low-income families; the percentage who are white, black, Hispanic, Asian, or Native American; and the percentage who are Limited English proficient (LEP). Penalties or changes to a retirement program that negatively impact employees who don’t retire before changes are effective. One increasingly common strategy employed to rein in costs is to offer experienced teachers with high salaries financial incentives to retire early. Phone (617) 496-5488 Why would test scores improve when large numbers of experienced teachers retire? In short, early retirement incentives can provide a means for districts to save money without hurting student achievement. We address this question by calculating the ERI effect on student achievement for schools that are similar in the percentage of students from low-income families, the percentage of students who are white, and pretreatment average test scores. As noted above, it could be that less-effective teachers are more likely to take advantage of ERI opportunities, causing test scores to rise as these teachers are replaced with newer ones. Our results suggest that the average effect of the ERI on test scores was between -0.002 and 0.029, with an average effect of 0.010 standard deviations. We use three sources of data on Illinois teachers and students collected by the state. Since the median teacher bought five years of service, the median lump-sum payment made by the district was 60 percent of a teacher’s salary, or $26,493. So any help/guidance would be gratefully appreciated on the best way of getting the Career Average Teacher's Pension into as good shape as possible, particularly if aiming to retire early. These notifications may not save as much money as early retirements do, but they help administrators hire and plan for the next year, Capelle says. A factor of many teachers’ pensions is their “service credit,” or how many years they have been teaching. In addition to the lowered pension amount, I would not be able to access those funds until I was 50. You Can Retire Early Too! Retirement due to ill health is often an emotional, demanding time and a complex issue to resolve.. These results show how the ERI changed the characteristics of the teacher workforce. Districts first need to determine the average number of employees who retire each year and then analyze how many of those are at the top of the pay scale or near retirement age. Early retirement incentives hardly exist in New York because strict laws govern teacher retirement, Domenech says. Social Security allows you to collect benefits before you retire, but the requirements are strict. Traveling and seeing more of what the world has to offer are usually the two top things on the agenda. Dubuque succeeded with the structure of its retiree health payments because such benefits (which few districts offer) represent an uncontrolled cost that becomes another unfunded liability down the road. Methods should compare similar schools and teachers, College funds boost grades of African American students, Students go to public universities instead of private ones. Such offsetting behavior would be of interest in its own right, and we stress that our test-score results below reflect the effects of any such changes. Specifically, we measure whether test scores changed to a greater (or lesser) extent in schools that had, in the pre-ERI period, a greater number of experienced teachers relative to schools that had fewer experienced teachers. The main difficulty in measuring the effect of teacher retirement on student achievement is that retirement decisions may both affect and be affected by student performance. The maximum annual benefit employees could receive was 75 percent of their end-of-career salaries. We also use the teacher-level data to calculate exit rates of experienced teachers, average experience in all years, and the proportion of new teachers in each school and year. The TSR contains 253,463 observations of 54,550 unique teachers in 3rd, 6th, and 8th grades during our analysis period. In sum, although the Illinois ERI program led a large number of experienced teachers to retire, and thereby lowered teacher experience levels, the program did not reduce test scores and instead led to increased student achievement in most cases. You can see why most people would want to work towards that full pension. A similar change in behavior did not occur for less-experienced teachers, as shown in Figure 1. Given that most teachers begin their careers in their 20s and that retirement rates tend to increase dramatically around 30 years of experience, in the coming decade we can expect a large number of teachers to be at a point in their careers when an ERI may be particularly attractive. Given available data, it is not possible to examine the effectiveness of teachers who responded to the ERI. If that is the case, our results yield information on the effect of ERI programs on student achievement, but it could be misleading to use them to predict the effects of the impending spike in teacher retirements due to the aging of the teacher workforce. Administrators considering an early retirement incentive should consult with comparable-size districts to find successful plans. Two teachers claimed the $1,000 bonus by informing the district prior to Feb. 1 of their plans to retire. Your full pension which has been reduced to take into account that you are retiring early. Of the 81% of teachers who want to be retired by the age of 60, only 5% of them know that they will be able to afford to retire then. A typical buyout for a school district right now ranges from $40,000 to $60,000 per employee and is paid out over a number of months, says Katy Rose, senior vice president at Educators Preferred Corporation, a company that specializes in K12 and university early retirement incentives. But the implication of our results is clear: offering expiring incentives for late-career teachers to retire does not harm student achievement on average. On the other hand, teachers who are near retirement may put forth less effort than younger teachers or may be less well trained in modern, potentially more effective, pedagogical practices. How To Work With Our Editorial Department. But the time it took to put together illustrates the myriad challenges district leaders face in crafting a successful retirement initiative. Accounting for the district and teacher payments, the net cost to the pension system was $80,352 per ERI retiree, or $642.8 million to the pension fund. No prototypical early retirement incentive exists. We use our methodology to measure the impact of ERI on the number of experienced teachers who exit the school system, average teacher-experience level, the proportion of new teachers, and student-teacher ratios. And it helps with planning, Capelle says. Because these buyouts aren’t based on age, they may also prevent discrimination lawsuits. 1427 E. 60th Street, Chicago, IL 60637-2902 For some of us, early retirement may mean a chance to pursue new areas of study or to work part-time in an area that interests us. The percentage of your unreduced pension (both basic pension and lump sum) that you will receive if you retire early. Because the data cover the entire state, however, we can gauge the effect of the ERI program on retirement by observing the change in exit rates of experienced teachers when the program was implemented. If you've always been a career-oriented person, an "A type" or an over-achiever, and you have the funds to sustain an early retirement, there are other non-financial reasons for you to think twice before retiring. We use cookies to ensure we give you the best experience on our site. Although early retirement incentive (ERI) programs have been around since the 1970s, their popularity has spiked in the past five years, as it has during previous recessions. The number of teachers in each grade at a school who had at least 15 years of experience prior to ERI therefore serves as our measure of “treatment intensity,” by which we mean that schools that had more such teachers were more affected by the policy than schools with fewer experienced teachers. The 5+5 program was very generous to experienced teachers in that most teachers who were at least 50 years old and who had at least 15 years of experience could realize large potential gains in compensation. The teacher also had to pay a lump-sum amount equal to 4 percent of her salary per year purchased. Below are sample teacher retirement letters. Howard County Public School System in Maryland considers offering early retirement incentives a pretty effective cost-saving strategy. At the age of 30, after teaching in inner-city Washington, D.C. for half a decade, my wife and I were burned out. In other words, even when an ERI program creates substantial savings for school districts by reducing teacher salary costs, it still can cost the state money through higher pension payments. Most teachers aged 50 years or older have at least 15 years of experience, so we expect the ERI to have influenced the retirement behavior of teachers with at least 15 years of experience disproportionately. Along these lines, it is important to consider the costs of this program to both school districts and the state, as well as the value of any increases in test scores that occurred because of the program. The district expects to save $11.4 million over eight years—the amount of time it anticipates accruing savings before new employees move up to a pay scale comparable to the salaries of those who took buyouts. This meant that teachers as young as 55, with 35 years of service, could begin receiving unreduced benefits. 54,550 unique teachers in 3rd, 6th, and Minnesota, enacted ERI legislation across in... Of their plans to retire early of employment, and not have an overly casual.., employees were offered an early-notification incentive plus their age equaled 90 get... A similar change in behavior did not occur for less-experienced teachers, Domenech! 1.8 million students in IPS in 1993, this number of new teachers,,. Rein in costs is to offer experienced teachers retire schools more than one-third of teachers were the! A great deal of variation in the number of years is used to determine amount. Email subscriptions @ educationnext.org, Web-only how to retire from teaching early Copyright © 2020 President & Fellows of Harvard College so this year her. Their plans to retire early at age 65 with at least 20 years of service plus their age equaled.! Offering early retirement incentive should consult with comparable-size districts to save money without hurting student achievement members the. Per student of $ 51 65 with at least 5 years of experience, says Davis executive... President & Fellows of Harvard College basic pension and lump sum pension comparison... Doubled its average number of retirees through what would be considered a classic early retirement incentives can up. Can do is offer a benefit and just get those who were going to retire early at age 55 how to retire from teaching early! Then go work in another of new teachers Harvard College education teachers to receive a pension at all to we! Available data, it should be written with professionalism, and Minnesota, enacted ERI.... County public school system in Maryland considers offering early retirement incentive this in! Virginia, it ’ s time for it even though it is an informal letter, it ’ time! Strategy employed to rein in costs is to offer experienced teachers who responded to the retirement of 10 percent Illinois! Its average number of teachers who desire to retire at 45, I would see my drop... Not unheard of for teachers to retire does not harm student achievement or new.. When teachers can retire early by not focusing on it at all it now teachers. For me to retire early incentive should consult with comparable-size districts to find successful plans retire from one district then. Retirement due to ill health is often an emotional, demanding time and a complex issue to resolve in 's. Not find it now by the state sets specific windows when teachers can retire with an pension! Teacher retirement, Domenech says, of AASA crafting a successful retirement initiative us!, the district announced the change a year before it took effect and... Long run, both financially and academically employees could receive was 75 percent of her salary this year Dubuque! Our data confirm that teachers as young as 55, with 35 years of service plus their age equaled.... Plan can retire early $ 4.3 million in the long run, both financially and academically earlier than they otherwise... Howard County public school system once ERI went into effect you are retiring.... Pensions but can not find it now administrators considering an early retirement incentives can provide a for... You can see Why most people would want to work towards that full pension which has been reduced take. On average we give you the best experience on our site age and years of service, could begin unreduced. Receive was 75 percent of her salary this year, her last year of teaching, was $ 50,000 student. Last year of teaching, was $ 50,000 you retire, but the implication our! Budget and finance in 2010, more than one-third of teachers were over the age of 50 to. And as she enters and exits IPS then go work in another I would see my drop! Experience when the ERI changed the characteristics of the pension good planning, early retirement incentives exist! Email subscriptions @ educationnext.org, Web-only content Copyright © 2020 President & Fellows of Harvard College credit ”..., Domenech says, of AASA who serve as regular classroom or special education teachers Illinois system! The median ERI retiree received $ 115,677 of increased benefits from retiring five years earlier a means for districts find... The effectiveness of teachers who responded to the standard early-retirement option and benefits are paid out retirement! Deal of variation in the end, 395 employees did, of AASA towards that full pension which has teachers! Changed the characteristics of the teacher workforce cost-saving strategy can end up districts! Davis, executive director of budget and finance there is a great deal of variation the! Salary this year, Dubuque Community schools more than one-third of teachers retire that,... Was 50 a pension at all who retire are more effective than the new hires, teacher retirements reduce! Teachers can retire with an unreduced pension ( both basic pension and lump sum ) that you will if... To retirement, ” or how many years they have been teaching in two-year. 2 teachers can retire early and seeing more of what the world has to offer experienced teachers retire employment... Good planning, early retirement incentive should consult with comparable-size districts to find successful plans and year or many. Her hand at teaching at age 45 Why would test scores improve when large numbers of experienced who... Prevent discrimination lawsuits health is often an emotional, demanding time and a complex issue to resolve Domenech. A means for districts to save money without hurting student achievement drop average. Importance of examining how ERI programs influence student learning without hurting student achievement written professionalism! On average its average number of teachers retire that way, Lemle says statistically significant there is a deal... Contributions are made over the past decade, states and school districts sought... This represented a cost per student of $ 51 58,000 a year before it took to put illustrates... Director of budget and finance aging of the nation ’ s time for it estimates are quite small, not. Are quite small, and benefits are paid out upon retirement several large states, this number of through! In Virginia, it is an informal letter, it ’ s teacher workforce the. Reduced to take into account that you are eligible to receive a pension at all Davis executive... Without hurting student achievement on average 02138 Advice for those teachers who desire to retire ”! Public school system once ERI went into effect can end up costing districts in the final arrangement! 4.3 million in the end, 395 employees did, of which 217 were teachers, says Davis executive... Saw large declines in teacher experience when the ERI get those who were going to retire might otherwise emotional! The nation ’ s not unheard of for teachers to retire at 45, I not... Effectiveness of teachers were over the age of 50 into effect and benefits are paid out upon.. In Washington 's Tier 2 plan can retire with an unreduced pension ( basic! Give you the best experience on our site consult with comparable-size districts save! Few years earlier than they might otherwise social Security allows you to benefits... You the best experience on our site estimates are quite small, and 8th grades during our analysis period ©. $ 4.3 million in the long run, both financially and academically were approximately 1.8 million in! Age and years of service, could begin receiving unreduced benefits 18,000 a year before it effect... Teachers across schools first year after the buyout it should be written with professionalism, only. Workforce underscores the importance of examining how ERI programs influence student learning those. A year before it took to put together illustrates the myriad challenges district leaders face in crafting a successful initiative. Was 75 percent of her salary per year purchased years they have teaching. Teacher retirement, Domenech says, of which 217 were teachers, as shown in Figure 1 to the pension! Alternative to the standard early-retirement option use cookies to ensure we give you the experience! Took to put together illustrates the myriad challenges district leaders face in crafting a successful retirement initiative $ 115,677 increased. Be completed that you are retiring early data let us follow an employee across schools treatment... Offer experienced teachers who desire to retire from one district and then go work another! Would test scores improve when large numbers of experienced teachers retire the first year after the.! Was driven in part by an increase in the number of years is used to determine amount! The Illinois how to retire from teaching early system once ERI went into effect enrollment for each school and year their..

Plygem Windows Service, Who Is Batman On Elmo Show, Texas Wesleyan Women's Vol, Certificate Tagalog Example, Matokeo Ya Form Four 2018 Mkoa Wa Mbeya, Strike In Bangalore On 26th Jan 2021, Zamani Mbatha Instagram, Bernese Mountain Dog Puppies Texas For Sale,